A Very Bookish Murder by Dee MacDonald (Ally McKinley Mystery #3), Reviewed

 

Dee MacDonald’s A Very Bookish Murder, the third installment in the Ally McKinley Mystery series, is a delightful cozy mystery that immerses readers in the charming Highland village of Locharran. As a first-time reader of MacDonald’s work, I was thoroughly enchanted by this fast-paced, engaging tale that blends a gripping whodunit with vivid characters and a picturesque Scottish setting.

 The story centers on Ally McKinley, a guesthouse owner and amateur sleuth who finds herself embroiled in yet another murder investigation. When renowned novelist Jodi Jones hosts a writers’ retreat in Locharran, Ally welcomes some of the attendees to her cozy Auld Malthouse B&B. The retreat takes a dark turn when Jodi is found strangled in the hotel’s ladies’ bathroom during the inaugural session. As Ally digs into the case—assisted by her faithful puppy Flora, her partner Ross, and a new detective, DI Amir Kandahar—the mystery deepens with accusations of plagiarism, infidelity, and hidden grudges among the retreat’s attendees. The stakes escalate when another writer, claiming to know the killer’s identity, is found dead, making it clear the murderer is still at large and determined to keep their secrets buried.

 MacDonald crafts a compelling mystery with a well-paced plot that keeps you guessing. The cast of characters—from the eclectic writers’ group to the quirky locals—brings Locharran to life, making it feel like a character in its own right. Ally is a relatable and likable protagonist, balancing her amateur sleuthing with warmth and wit, while DI Kandahar’s fresh perspective and surprising respect for Ally’s insights add a new dynamic to the series. The subplot involving the dramatic delivery of twin heirs to the Countess of Locharran adds a heartwarming layer to the story, showcasing MacDonald’s knack for weaving personal moments into the suspense.

 The book’s cozy atmosphere, with its quaint Scottish setting and minimal gore, makes it a perfect read for fans of bloodless mysteries. While it stands alone well, the rich character development and hints of past adventures left me eager to dive into the first two books in the series. The climactic “ah-ha” moment is both satisfying and thrilling, tying up loose ends while keeping the stakes high.

 Overall, A Very Bookish Murder is a captivating, character-driven mystery that delivers on both plot and charm. Dee MacDonald has crafted a series that’s sure to delight cozy mystery enthusiasts. Highly recommended for anyone who loves a clever puzzle set in a cozy Highland village!

 You can order your copy here.

 Rating: 4.5/5 stars

 As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 I received a complimentary ​digital copy of this book​ from NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.